Why your pay gap figure won't move until you fix the systems behind it
HR Directors are often asked to explain, and to fix, numbers they didn't create. You produce the pay gap report and meet your reporting obligations, and still the figure barely shifts while the questions get harder. This article explains why that happens and what actually changes it.
- The questions are getting harder, and a published report no longer answers them
The pressure on HR leaders comes from several directions at once. Investors ask about ethnicity pay gaps, whether diversity is clustered at the bottom of the organisation or present in senior leadership, and how people of faith and disabled colleagues are supported. Large customers vet their supply chains for pay transparency, so a supplier that can't demonstrate real action risks losing the contract. Regulation elsewhere, such as the EU Pay Transparency Directive, filters through to UK organisations with multinational ties and supply chains, even where it doesn't apply directly. Legislation is also moving beyond data reporting towards prescribed action plans on specific topics such as menopause.
The common thread is that stakeholders want evidence of action, not just a published figure. Waiting also carries a financial cost.
A 2022 Gartner study found that the average cost of correcting pay gaps rises by around $439,000 for every year an organisation fails to act.
2. The figure is a symptom, and most initiatives don't touch the cause
Many organisations respond with leadership courses for women, race equity training and a well-publicised report. After years of this, the gaps stay the same or get worse. That isn't because the people involved lack capability or commitment. These initiatives sit alongside the systems that produce the gap rather than changing them.
In my experience, those systems fail in two places. The first is retention. Many organisations lose women one to two years after maternity leave, because the person who returns has different needs and the organisation hasn't changed to meet them. A significant part of the pay gap is a retention problem rather than a starting-salary problem. The second is progression. Many systems are built to advance a narrow pool of people, so others are structurally held back however hard they work. You'll hear it in the language managers use: "she's not ready yet". Ask what readiness looks like and how it is being developed, and there is rarely a clear answer. That is a missing system, not a capability gap.
This is why it can feel as though you are doing everything right and still seeing no movement. You are measuring the outcome while the cause goes unexamined.
3. Fixing the system produces measurable results, if the right pieces are in place
When the work is aimed at the systems, change follows quickly. An engineering client of mine took an honest look at how their bonus and promotion processes operated in practice rather than on paper. Within 12 months they saw an 8.3% reduction in the gender pay gap bonus figure, a 15% increase in female promotions and a 5% increase in women receiving bonuses, driven by promotions into bonus-eligible roles. The headline pay gap moved more slowly, as you would expect, because it reflects the whole workforce and structural change takes years. These leading indicators show the system is working, so track them rather than judging progress by the headline alone.
Results like these depend on four things.
- A functioning system needs time, effort, money and accountability, and the absence of any one of them stalls it.
- It needs managers who can connect ambitious targets to their daily decisions, because targets fail when managers don't know what is expected of them.
- It also needs the right external support. Lived experience gives data its meaning, but without understanding organisational mechanics, metrics and best practice, it can produce a narrow lens and even cause harm. When you appoint a partner, look for both.
- A robust system also gives you a steady, data-driven footing when the unexpected happens, and lets you communicate honestly with employees and customers about what is working and what isn't.
Where to start
If you are publishing pay gap data but not seeing it move, or facing investor, customer or legislative questions you aren't confident answering, a conversation is a sensible first step. I work with organisations to identify where their progression, bonus and retention systems are failing, to build the case for change that managers will buy into, and to put in place the accountability that makes it last.
Book a call with me to talk through where your systems stand and what to prioritise first.